Cross-border contracts with consumers (b2c). Selling to consumers abroad: opportunities and legal pitfalls

Cross-border trade offers Belgian businesses significant growth opportunities. With an online shop, you can reach consumers in other European countries with little effort. But what if a consumer abroad doesn’t pay an invoice? Can you sue them in Belgium? And is a clause in your terms and conditions choosing Belgian law and the Belgian courts enough? Often, it isn’t. EU law protects consumers as the economically weaker and legally less experienced party. If you direct your activities at their country, consumers will generally enjoy the protection of the law and the courts of the country where they live. For Belgian businesses, this can have significant practical and financial consequences. If you don’t direct your activities at their country, the picture is different.

Which law applies?

In principle, the parties are free to choose the law that governs their contract (Article 3 of the Rome I Regulation). A Belgian business can therefore opt for Belgian law in its terms and conditions.

For consumer contracts, however, that freedom has limits. Article 6 of the Rome I Regulation lays down special rules where the business pursues its commercial activities in the country where the consumer is habitually resident, or directs those activities at that country, and the contract falls within the scope of those activities. In that case:

  • a choice of law cannot deprive consumers of the protection they enjoy under the mandatory rules of their own country’s law;
  • where no law has been chosen, the contract is governed by the law of the country where the consumer is habitually resident.

A Belgian business that actively sells its products in France can, for example, choose Belgian law. French consumers nevertheless keep the mandatory protection of French consumer law, to the extent that it offers them more.

If the conditions of Article 6 are not met, the general rules of the Rome I Regulation apply (Articles 3 and 4). Be careful with services, too: the special rules do not apply where the services are supplied exclusively outside the country where the consumer is habitually resident (Article 6(4)(a)). There is no such exception in the jurisdiction rules discussed below, so the applicable law and the competent court do not always go hand in hand.

Which court has jurisdiction?

Articles 17 to 19 of the Brussels I bis Regulation determine where a cross-border consumer dispute may be brought. These protective rules apply in particular where the business directs its commercial activities at the Member State where the consumer is domiciled and the contract falls within the scope of those activities (Article 17(1)(c)).

Where that is the case, the rules work in the consumer’s favour:

  • Consumers may sue the business either in the courts of the Member State where the business is established, or in the courts for the place where they themselves are domiciled.
  • The business may, in principle, only sue consumers in the courts of the Member State where they are domiciled.

A Belgian business claiming payment from a consumer living in France, at whom it directed its activities, will therefore have to sue that consumer in France.

The Brussels I bis Regulation applies within the European Union. For consumers in Switzerland, Norway and Iceland, similar rules apply under the Lugano Convention. Different rules apply to other countries, such as the United Kingdom.

When does a business “direct” its activities at another country?

It is not enough that a website can be accessed from abroad – something more is needed. Relevant factors include:

  • the business advertises expressly in the consumer’s country;
  • the website mentions customers abroad or deliveries to that country;
  • the business uses a domain name of the consumer’s country or a neutral domain name such as .com or .eu;
  • the website offers tailored languages, prices, delivery options or contact details;
  • the business runs targeted online campaigns in that country;
  • the business lists international telephone numbers or directions from other countries.

No single factor is always decisive on its own. The court looks at all the circumstances together.

Even where consumers contact a Belgian business on their own initiative, a closer look is needed. What matters is not who made first contact, but whether the business was directing its activities at the consumer’s country before the contract was concluded.

What if you don’t direct your activities at the consumer’s country?

In that case, the protective jurisdiction rules of Articles 17 to 19 do not apply. Instead, the general jurisdiction rules of the Brussels I bis Regulation apply:

  • Consumer’s domicile (Article 4). You can always sue consumers in the Member State where they are domiciled.
  • Place of performance (Article 7(1)). You can also sue in the courts for the place where, under the contract, the services were provided or the goods were or should have been delivered. If that place is in Belgium, a Belgian court may have jurisdiction.
  • Jurisdiction clause (Article 25). A clause choosing the Belgian courts can then, in principle, be relied on. It is, however, still subject to the rules on unfair terms. The Court of Justice has held that a clause conferring exclusive jurisdiction on the court where the business has its registered office may be unfair towards a consumer.

Whether you directed your activities at the consumer’s country is therefore often what decides whether you can bring proceedings in Belgium.

Can you choose a Belgian court in your terms and conditions?

If you direct your activities at the consumer’s country, a clause agreed in advance giving the Belgian courts exclusive jurisdiction will usually not help. A jurisdiction clause then only has effect within the limits of Article 19 (Article 25(4) of the Brussels I bis Regulation).

Under Article 19, the protective jurisdiction rules can only be departed from in a limited number of cases:

  • the agreement is entered into after the dispute has arisen;
  • the agreement allows the consumer to bring proceedings in other courts;
  • the business and the consumer were both domiciled or habitually resident in the same Member State when the contract was concluded, and the agreement confers jurisdiction on the courts of that Member State, provided that its law allows this.

A clause agreed in advance that requires a consumer abroad to litigate exclusively in Belgium can therefore, in principle, not be enforced against them.

Belgian law also restricts jurisdiction clauses. Article VI.83, 23° of the Belgian Code of Economic Law prohibits clauses that designate a court other than the one designated by Article 624, 1°, 2° and 4° of the Belgian Judicial Code. A prohibited unfair term is void (Article VI.84 of the Code of Economic Law).

What if the consumer enters an appearance in Belgium anyway?

If you sue a consumer from abroad in Belgium and they enter an appearance without contesting the Belgian court’s jurisdiction, that court will in principle have jurisdiction (Article 26 of the Brussels I bis Regulation). This applies to consumers as well.

However, the court must first inform the consumer of their right to contest jurisdiction and of the consequences of entering an appearance. So don’t count on it: consumers are expressly made aware of their protection.

What does this mean for your business?

If a consumer abroad doesn’t pay, you may have to bring proceedings in their country of residence. That can mean additional costs, for example for:

  • a lawyer in that country;
  • translations;
  • service of documents and other procedural steps;
  • following up and enforcing the judgment.

Limit the risk before you deliver

The most effective protection often lies not in your terms and conditions, but in how you structure payment.

Full payment upfront

Have customers abroad pay when they place their order or before delivery. This works best for standard products and online sales.

A sufficient deposit

Ask for a deposit before you start that covers at least your initial costs and work. Make clear when the balance falls due.

Staged payments

Link each instalment to a clearly defined stage, and only start the next stage once the previous invoice has been paid. This approach works best for services, bespoke work and long-term assignments.

A credit limit

Cap the amount that can be outstanding at any one time. This stops a single default from turning into a substantial claim.

These measures don’t change which court has jurisdiction or which law protects the consumer. They do, however, limit the amount your business has to recover if a customer fails to pay.

Cross-border debt recovery

Is a customer abroad still not paying? FAIRWAY first looks at:

  • whether your business directed its activities at the consumer’s country;
  • which court has international jurisdiction;
  • which law governs the contract;
  • whether the consumer disputes the invoice;
  • which simplified European procedure is available;
  • what recovery will cost;
  • whether proceedings make economic sense;
  • how a judgment can be enforced.

FAIRWAY assists businesses with disputed invoices and cross-border debt recovery. Where needed, we work with specialist law firms in the consumer’s country.

That way, you don’t automatically end up in costly proceedings abroad, but choose the approach that is legally feasible and economically sound.

Contact

Does your business sell products or services to consumers in other European countries, or are you facing an unpaid invoice from abroad? FAIRWAY assesses which court has jurisdiction, which law applies and which recovery strategy is legally feasible and economically sound. ContactFAIRWAY to find out more.

This page contains general legal information and does not constitute legal advice regarding your specific situation. Please contact FAIRWAY for personalised advice tailored to your case.

Make an appointment

Contact us for more information or to schedule an appointment.

info@fairway.law
Monday - Friday 09h.00-18h.00

About Us

Thanks to our decades of in-house experience across various areas of law, our multidisciplinary team is ideally positioned to assist you with a wide range of matters — at every stage of your legal project.

General terms and conditions
Privacy Policy
Cookie Policy